top of page
Search

Where to Give Birth in Middle Tennessee: A Local Doula's Honest Guide

By Amanda Githaiga | Rose Birth Services



 It Matters Where You Birth


When you’re planning one of the most sacred, powerful days of your life — location matters. As a doula who has supported hundreds of families in and around Nashville, I’ve had a front-row seat inside nearly every hospital and birth center in Middle Tennessee.


This guide isn’t about fluff or Google reviews. It’s about the real experience: the birth culture, the provider relationships, and the policies that actually affect your options, your peace, and your power during birth.



Let’s walk through some of the most common birthing locations in the area and what you should know before choosing.







Vanderbilt is one of the most well-known teaching hospitals in Tennessee and one of the highest-volume birth locations in the state. It’s big, it’s busy, and it’s medically robust — but that doesn’t always translate to a gentle, supported birth experience.


Pros: 

✔️ Level IV NICU and full-spectrum high-risk support 

✔️ A few hydrotherapy tubs (though they’re not always available — first come first served!) 

✔️ The Melrose Midwives are a trusted, natural-minded option in a very medical space

 ✔️ New policy update that welcomes doulas into the OR if a caesarean is the path birth takes. 


Cons: 

✖️ Labor and delivery nurses vary widely in their experience — some have never supported an unmedicated birth 

✖️ The size and pace of the hospital can feel overwhelming without serious preparation 

✖️ Policies can be rigid and hard to work around without advocacy


C-Section Rate: ~32%


Doula Insight: Vandy isn’t impossible for the natural-minded mama — but it’s not for the faint of heart, either. It can work beautifully if you’re committed to preparation, walk in with a clear plan, and bring the right support team (yes, a doula makes a difference here). This is a hospital where you’ll need to know what you want — and how to ask for it.







 This is Nashville’s busiest maternity hospital — and it shows. Often dubbed a “baby mill” by birth workers, it’s a high-volume, high-efficiency facility that’s seen everything. But for many families, it’s accessible, centrally located, and a viable option with the right provider in your corner.


Pros: 

✔️ Some labor rooms are equipped with tubs for hydrotherapy (though not for waterbirth) 

✔️ Fairly respectful of well-communicated birth plans 

✔️ Certified doulas (🙋‍♀️ like me!) are allowed in the OR for cesarean births


Cons: 

✖️ Hustle culture is real — this hospital runs on speed and efficiency 

✖️ Many nurses and residents haven’t been trained to support undisturbed, physiological birth 

✖️ Their birth center sounds ideal — but you can risk out quickly (even one high blood pressure reading in triage can do it)


Preferred Providers: Connectus Midwives, Dr. Clendenin and The Women's OB team.


C-Section Rate: ~34%


Doula Insight: Midtown isn’t cozy, but it can work — especially if you know your rights, choose a supportive provider, and walk in with a birth plan and a solid team behind you. This is not a go-with-the-flow hospital. But with me on your team? We navigate it well, even in the OR if needed.










Centennial is often overlooked, but it’s one of Nashville’s best-kept secrets for families wanting more presence and less pressure. Smaller and slower-paced than Vanderbilt or Midtown, it offers a refreshing middle ground between clinical care and personal attention.


Pros: 

✔️ Absolutely stellar nursing staff — warm, respectful, and often doula-friendly 

✔️ Tends to give more space and time during labor than high-volume hospitals 

✔️ Feels less rushed and more responsive to families’ preferences


Cons: 

✖️ L&D space is generally available, but the more luxurious birth suites with tubs (located on another floor) are sometimes closed due to staffing shortages 

✖️ Most providers lean toward the medical model, so choosing the right one is key 

✖️ Doula access in the OR is inconsistent — no official policy, and it depends on who’s on shift



Preferred Providers: Dr. Clendenin and the Women's OB team  


C-Section Rate: ~30%


Doula Insight: If you’re looking for hospital birth without the frenzy, Centennial is a top-tier option. The nursing care alone makes it worth considering. It’s a place where your birth plan is more likely to be honored — especially if you bring a provider who respects it and a doula who knows how to advocate when the lines get blurry (even in the OR, if we’re lucky).






NorthCrest feels like the small-town best friend of Middle Tennessee birth options. The pace is slower, the staff is sweeter, and there’s a gentleness to the entire experience that makes it a favorite among mamas craving calm over clinical.


Pros: 

✔️ Truly kind and attentive nursing staff — think Southern hospitality in scrubs 

✔️ Garden tubs in every room (not for delivery, but wonderful for labor support) 

✔️ Intimate setting that doesn’t feel like a birth factory


Cons: 

✖️ Water birth is not permitted (but you can still labor in the tub) 

✖️ Fewer amenities than larger hospitals — simple, not fancy


Preferred Provider: Diana Health 


C-Section Rate: ~26%


Doula Insight: If your dream is a peaceful, low-intervention birth in a space that feels more like a guest room than a hospital ward — this is it. The staff knows how to support unmedicated labor, and you’re far more likely to get consistent care from people who actually listen. No flash, but plenty of heart.






Summit is a small, lower-volume hospital on the east side of Nashville. While it leans more clinical in feel compared to other cozy options, it’s often praised for being easy to navigate and relatively calm. It’s not fancy — but it can offer a steady, supportive experience if you know what to expect and come prepared.



Pros: 

✔️ Fewer rigid protocols than higher-volume hospitals 

✔️ Friendly, approachable staff who tend to respect birth preferences 

✔️ Easy to navigate and rarely chaotic


Cons: 

✖️ The overall vibe is more medical than maternal — not the warmest or most intimate setting 

✖️ Basic amenities — no tubs, limited space for movement and comfort tools


Preferred Provider: Dr. McGuire 


C-Section Rate: ~28%


Doula Insight: If you’re local and looking for a straightforward, no-fuss birth experience — Summit can absolutely work. Just know it’s not the most natural-friendly spot in town, so clarity, confidence, and advocacy go a long way.





StoneCrest might not be the first hospital that comes up in your search — but don’t let that fool you. This lesser-known facility is often a quiet win for families who want a respectful, steady, and relatively low-intervention birth without the downtown hustle.


Pros: 

✔️ Staff is generally respectful of unmedicated birth and individualized plans 

✔️ One room features a labor tub (for labor only, not waterbirth) 

✔️ Slower pace compared to larger hospitals — fewer distractions, more calm


Cons: 

✖️ Because of gaining popularity it is often bustling with patients

✖️ Doulas should be allowed in the OR per policy, but in reality, it’s hit-or-miss depending on the team on shift


Preferred Provider: Diana Health 


C-Section Rate: ~27%


Doula Insight: If you’re near Smyrna and want solid, drama-free care without feeling overly medicalized, StoneCrest is a solid option. It’s not fancy, but it is functional — and when you pair that with a supportive provider like Diana Health, you can absolutely have a strong, centered birth here.





On the surface, Hendersonville isn’t known for being VBAC-friendly — in fact, it’s quite the opposite. But there’s one major exception: Dr. Riggan. He’s gained a quiet reputation in the birth community as a compassionate, skilled VBAC advocate who helps women navigate a system that otherwise leans heavily toward repeat cesareans.



Pros: 

✔️ Easy to navigate

✔️ Dr. Riggan offers truly VBAC-supportive care in a hospital that otherwise isn’t known for it


Cons: 

✖️ The hospital itself is not VBAC-friendly by culture or policy 

✖️ Amenities are minimal — no frills, tubs, nitrous or physiologic birth tools 

✖️ Doulas are not currently permitted in the OR

✖️ VERY against photography/videography


Preferred Provider: Dr. Riggan 


C-Section Rate: ~25%


Doula Insight: Hendersonville isn’t ideal if you’re seeking a naturally minded or VBAC-supportive hospital culture — unless you’re under the care of Dr. Riggan. He’s the reason this hospital is even on the list. If you're pursuing a VBAC and he’s available to you, it can be a strong option — just know that OR policies are still restrictive, and advocacy will matter here more than most places.




The only facility in Middle Tennessee supporting of water birth, Vanderbilt Birth Center provides a serene, home-like environment with queen-sized beds, hydrotherapy tubs, and a midwife-led model of care. However, its strict eligibility criteria mean that not all who plan to birth here will do so.



Pros: 

✔️ Beautiful, homey atmosphere with large tubs and tranquil birth suites 

✔️ Waterbirth is fully supported and encouraged 

✔️ Midwife-led care focused on low-intervention birth


Cons: 

✖️ Very narrow eligibility — even minor risk factors can lead to transfer 

✖️ Certain procedures and tests are mandatory; opting out may disqualify you 

✖️ No epidurals available — a change in pain management plans necessitates transfer



Transfer Rates:

  • Before Labor (Antepartum): Approximately 34% of patients are transferred to hospital care before labor begins due to emerging risk factors or complications.

  • During Labor (Intrapartum): About 18% are transferred during labor for reasons such as stalled labor progression or pain management needs. Vanderbilt University


Doula Insight: Vanderbilt Birth Center is ideal for low-risk mamas seeking a birth center vibe with hospital proximity. However, be prepared for the possibility of transfer. If you do risk out, you'll be transferred to the Melrose Midwives, a highly respected hospital-based midwifery practice known for supporting natural birth plans. Either way, you're still in good hands — but it's important to walk in with your eyes open.





Despite glowing public reviews and impressive accolades, Williamson Medical Center is widely known among birth professionals as one of the least supportive environments for physiologic, low-intervention birth. It may look great on paper, but the lived experience? It’s a different story.


Pros: 

✔️ One room with tub for hydrotherapy

✔️ Waterbirth is fully supported and encouraged 

✔️ Midwife-led care focused on low-intervention birth


Cons: 

✖️ Intervention-heavy environment with some of the highest induction and cesarean rates in the region 

✖️ Very little tolerance for physiologic birth — standard procedures are rarely flexible 

✖️ Providers frequently override birth plans in the name of efficiency, control and “safety”


C-Section Rate: ~39%


Doula Insight: I’ll be honest — this is the one location on this list I actively encourage clients to avoid if they desire a natural, respectful, or individualized birth experience. The culture here is deeply medicalized and policy-driven, to the point where even something as simple as diffusing lavender oil is off-limits. If that sounds absurd to you, you’re not wrong — and you have better options just down the road.








Maury Regional doesn’t have all the bells and whistles of newer city hospitals, but what it does have is kindness. The facility is dated, but the nursing staff is known for being warm, patient, and respectful—which can make all the difference. It’s a straightforward space with compassionate care and a slower pace that many families appreciate.


Pros:

✔️ Kind, respectful nursing staff

✔️ Small-town feel and slower-paced care

✔️ Easy to navigate

✔️ Lower-than-average C-section rate


Cons:

✖️ No labor tubs or hydrotherapy options

✖️ Very limited physiologic birth tools

✖️ Doulas are not permitted in the OR for cesareans

✖️ Older facility with minimal amenities


Preferred Providers: Dr. Andres Rodriguez, Dr. Nicole Falls


C-Section Rate: ~23%


Doula Insight: Maury Regional offers no-frills maternity care, but for some families, the warmth of the staff and lower-intervention culture makes up for what the space lacks in amenities. If you’re not looking for all the extras and are focused on being treated with dignity and kindness, this hospital is worth considering. Just know that support tools are minimal and OR policies remain strict—so coming in informed and prepared is still key.





Saint Thomas Rutherford is a larger, medically oriented hospital serving Murfreesboro and much of south‑central Middle Tennessee. It has a well‑resourced labor & delivery unit connected to advanced care like a Level II NICU and lactation support, and does offer comfort features such as a labor tub through its Naturally Nurtured Birth Program. That said, the culture tends to lean more intervention‑focused, and support for physiological birth can vary widely depending on provider and nursing team.


Pros:✔️ Large, well‑resourced hospital with comprehensive obstetric and neonatal care, including a Level II NICU

✔️ Comfort features in birthing suites (aromatherapy, birthing balls, labor tub available under the Naturally Nurtured Birth Program)

✔️ Doulas are permitted c-sections when certified.


Cons:

✖️ Culture tends toward medical intervention (including earlier inductions)

✖️ Physiologic birth support can be inconsistent depending on team and shift

✖️ Amenity availability (like labor tub use) may depend on staffing and specific policy on a given day


Preferred Provider: Dr. Leinart


C‑Section Rate: ~43% (significantly above national average, indicating a more intervention‑oriented setting)


Doula Insight: Saint Thomas Rutherford has the infrastructure and support tools many families appreciate — including a Naturally Nurtured Birth Program with a labor tub and other comfort options. But this hospital generally operates from a more medically “default” perspective, and interventions like induction are more common than at naturally‑leaning birth centers or some smaller hospitals. If you choose this setting, clear communication about your preferences and active advocacy are important, and having a doula who knows how to navigate both supportive practices and institutional protocols can make a meaningful difference.




Why This Matters


Where you birth shapes what support you have, how free you are to labor instinctively, and whether your preferences will be honored or challenged. Choosing a birth location (and PROVIDER) isn’t just about distance from home — it’s about alignment.


And no matter how "natural-friendly" a hospital may seem, it’s still a hospital. That means liability concerns, protocols designed for efficiency, and an undercurrent of fear and worst-case-scenario thinking will always be part of the equation.


Even with a kind nurse or a great OB, the system is built around managing risk — not necessarily supporting instinct. And if your birth falls even slightly outside the box — VBAC, breech, multiples, or postdates — the skill, flexibility, and support available often drop dramatically. Policies take over. Options narrow.


But here’s the truth: just because you’re birthing in a hospital doesn’t mean you have to subscribe to that mindset. You can be informed. You can be prepared. You can stay anchored in peace while navigating a medical setting.


That’s exactly why I designed Born to Bloom — my faith-rooted childbirth course designed to equip you with the knowledge, language, and spiritual grounding to birth confidently, no matter where you are.


And when you work with me as your doula, access to the entire Born to Bloom course is included.


Together, we build a birth plan rooted in your values — not just hospital policy.



Explore Your Birth Options Inside Born to Bloom

Born to Bloom is my Christian childbirth academy designed to help you:

  • Understand the pros and cons of each setting

  • Ask better questions

  • Build a plan that aligns with your faith and values

  • Walk into birth confident, not confused



This isn’t just about a room. It’s about the environment that will hold you while you do the most powerful work of your life.



🌸 Ready to Feel Held and Prepared?

✨ Explore Born to Bloom – The Christian childbirth course for women who want more than just information.

✨ Learn About Doula Support – See how we can walk this path together, from pregnancy through postpartum.

Because birth was never meant to be endured — it was meant to be embodied. Let’s make sure you don’t walk into it alone.

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page